State terrorism can be directed externally against foreign adversaries or internally against domestic enemies. This is similar to igor primoratzs definition in state terrorism, in tony coady and michael okeefe, eds. The philosophical issues offers insight into many of the important philosophical issues surrounding terrorism. Whether it can be justified is an empirical question. Or should we restrict such actions to acts performed by nonstate organisations. Click download or read online button to get terrorism as a political philosophy book now. The effects of terrorism and counterterrorism measures on the enjoyment of childrens rights submission to the high commissioners report on terrorism and human rights by child rights international network crin. A philosophical investigation, by igor primoratz even it is not directly done, you can know even more regarding this life, regarding the. There are also quite a few historical studies of some other instances of state terrorism, most notably of the period of the great terror in the soviet union. As a current student on this bumpy collegiate pathway, i stumbled upon course hero, where i can find study resources for nearly all my courses, get online help from tutors 247, and even share my old projects, papers, and lecture notes with other students. Abstract my aim in this paper is not to try to formulate the meaning the word terrorismhas in ordinary use.
On the concept of terrorism 195 r 2009 palgrave macmillan 14708914 contemporary political theory vol. This essay is a critical philosophical analysis of the concept of state terrorism based upon an epistemological discussion. It seems to me that it would not make much sense to speak of nonviolent terrorism in the sense which also excludes threats of violence. Parent title 773t terrorism the philosophical issues. Israels state terrorism by lev grinberg, published on monday, april 1, 2002 by tikkun magazine michael stohl, the superpowers and international terror, paper presented at the annual meeting of the international studies association, atlanta, march 27april 1, 1984. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading terrorism. Despite these successes, the terrorist landscape remained complex in 2018.
Countering terrorism terrorist groups such as isis, alqaida, and hizballah continue to plot attacks against the united states and our allies and partners. Philosopher igor primoratz provides four reasons why he believes that state terrorism is typically morally worse than nonstate terrorism. A philosophical investigation kindle edition by primoratz, igor. It is this last element targeting innocent civilians that stands out in efforts to distinguish state terrorism from other forms of state violence. Prominent philosophers discuss definitions of terrorism, various approaches to its moral evaluation, and the contentious subject of state terrorism. The role of internet intermediaries in tackling terrorism online raphael cohenalmagor introduction. In a contemporary setting, however, state terrorism is apparently much more.
Contemporary state terrorism this volume aims to bring the state back into terrorism studies and fill the notable gap that currently exists in our understanding of the ways in which states employ terrorism as a political strategy of internal governance or foreign policy. State terrorism and counterterrorism charles sturt. Terrorism can dramatically influence the world, as shown by the farreaching. Terrorism and counterterrorism notes terrorism and.
Terrorism by states is characterized by official government support for policies of violence, repression, and intimidation. Some nontotalitarian states have resorted to terrorism against enemy civilians as a method of warfare, most notably when the raf and usaaf bombed german and japanese cities in world war ii see lackey 2004. Developing a gametheoritic analysis of terrorism scholarworks. State terrorism refers to acts of terrorism which a state conducts against another state or against. As primoratz notes, many this to be a general problem with consequentialism. Disregarding the criticisms advocating against the existence of state terrorism as a. Terrorism, counterterrorism and torture 2 actions or situations serves to justify human rights violations that otherwise would be unacceptable to the public. It presents generalizations about terrorisma form of political violence by, for, and against the stateand politics and violence based on the theories of. The author draws on a number of disciplines including sociology, psychology, and history to help clarify matters of terrorism that defy simle definitions and categorization. An earlier, shorter version of the first three sections of this chapter was read at the workshop terrorism and justice at the centre for applied philosophy and public ethics, university of melbourne, on november 2, 2001, and published in t. I agree that the ethics of terrorism is more than a footnote to the ethics of violence, but not for the reason adduced by wellman. If terrorism is a type of violence, does it have to be against persons, or should. For example, a texas physician imported plague germs from africa in a vial in his pocket.
The role of the united states is central in this analysis. This paper demonstrates knowledge and assimilation of terrorism perspectives, counter and antiterrorism, and aspects relating to prediction, prevention, mitigation, preparedness, response and postresponse recovery activities and analyze it in terms of how it would be dealt with it in terms of a counterterrorism plan that includes. The first comprehensive discussion of all the main philosophical issues raised by terrorism against the background of its past and recent developments. The author looks at arguments that suggest terrorism and the response to it are not as easily distinguishable as they may seem. Declaring war and sending the military to fight other militaries is not terrorism, nor is the use of violence to punish criminals who have been convicted of violent crimes. The latter is nicely encapsulated in the expression the war against terrorism. Country reports on terrorism 2017 is submitted in compliance with title 22 of the united states code, section 2656f the act, which requires the department of state to provide to congress a full and complete annual report on terrorism for those countries and groups meeting. Encylopedia article on state terrorism created date. Thats why terrorism a philosophical introduction by igor primoratz caught my eye because its rooted in the abstract principles of philosophy to ask whether terrorist acts have a moral foundation that. State terrorism, critical legal studies, philosophy, law, human rights. This paper examines and juxtaposes discourses about terrorism, violence, and political leadership.
The effects of terrorism and counterterrorism measures on. Across the cold war and the collapse of greatpower socialism, anthropological studies of violence have focused on international patterns of revolution, counterinsurgency warfare, state terrorism, militant ethnic nationalism, communal violence, and organized crime wolf 1969. We are supposed to wage war against terrorism but exactly what we are. The event provided an opportunity for a bilateral exchange on counterterrorism best practice between the uk and turkey, as well as a. Young peoples perspectives hussain aljabir developing community partnerships a practical solution for peace, prosperity and justice nick maurice the muslim demand curve for u. Within this broader context, the volume has a number of specific aims. Hoffman, a professor at georgetown university and a former senior executive of. State terrorism is usually the most organized and potentially the. Identity, selfdetermination and secession edited by igor primoratz, aleksandar pavkovic. State terrorism can be directed internally against domestic enemies, or externally against adversaries in the international domain.
A philosophical investigation, by igor primoratz even it is not directly done, you can know even more regarding this life, regarding the globe. While it is well known that many states around the world systematically practice torture, none of these states has the. It first looks to define terrorism and then looks at state terrorism and counter terrorism. Terrorism as a political philosophy download ebook pdf. It is addressed to state authorities, national and international nongovernmental organizations ngos, national human rights institutions, legal practitioners and individuals concerned with ensuring the protection and promotion of human rights in the context of terrorism and counter.
Also included are four case studies, showing how the concepts and. As the threats posed by these organizations continue to evolve, the department of state works to build global consensus to degrade and defeat these adversaries. My aim is rather to try for a definition that captures the trait, or traits, of terrorism which cause most of us to view it with moral repugnance. Definition of terrorism social and political effects introduction social structure and order, governance of society and politics are dependent on good communication, and good communication requires agreement on definitions of terminology. Historians of the french revolution have analyzed and discussed that case in great detail. Primoratz, state terrorism and counterterrorism, in terrorism. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. First, because of the nature of the modern state and the amount and variety of resources available even for small states, the state mode of terrorism claims vastly more victims than does terrorism by non. Also included are four case studies, showing how the concepts and arguments philosophers deploy in discussing violence, war and terrorism apply to particular instances of both insurgent and state. Igor primoratz defines terrorism as the deliberate use of violence, or the threat of its use, against innocent people, with the aim of intimidating them, or other people, into a course of action they would not otherwise take. Definition of terrorism social and political effects.
Asymmetric warfare refers to the use of randomunpredictable violence by a weak group i. Prominent philosophers discuss definitions of terrorism, various approaches to its moral evaluation, and the contentious subject of state. After presenting his definition of terrorism, primoratz evaluates consequentialist and deontological justifications of terrorism. According to igor primoratz, both the nazis and the soviets sought to impose total political. National strategy for combating terrorism focuses on identifying and defusing threats before they reach our borders. The report also describes examples where states have used this term to justify illegal actions that have little or no relevance with what the public understands. University of melbourne press, melbourne walzer, michael 1977 just and unjust wars. Countering terrorism united states department of state. In both cases, primoratzs definition fails because it includes an activity that would not commonly be called terrorism. Primoratz, igor 2003 state terrorism and counterterrorism. However, state terrorism is not the preserve of totalitarian regimes. Primoratz makes this point in state terrorism and counter terrorism, in igor primoratz, ed. Igor primoratz defines terrorism as the deliberate use of violence, or the threat of its use, against innocent people, with the aim of intimidating them, or other people, into a course of. Terrorism and counterterrorism it has been argued that a terrorist state is logically impossible by virtue of the definition of state.
Another, related double standard is state use of force vs. Foreign policy charles kurzman behind closed doors ten years of secret evidence and human suff ering. It is an attempt to reformulate the question of terrorism by making. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. While we appreciate the nature of the difficult challenge before us, our strategy is based on the belief that sometimes the most difficult tasks are accomplished by the most direct means. Bruce hoffman and marc sageman two of the nations preeminent terrorism. Terrorism, security, and the threat of counterterrorism. In such a context, can we speak of state terrorism, or should the word be. State terrorism and counterterrorism professor igor primoratz centre for applied philosophy and public ethics working paper number 20023 centre for applied philosophy and public ethics cappe cappe melbourne cappe canberra department of philosophy gpo box a260 university of melbourne australian national university parkville, victoria, 3010. Through a combination of diplomatic engagement and. State terrorism and counterterrorism electronic resource igor primoratz.
454 287 1354 1657 1081 1231 102 63 617 551 1162 846 1327 839 1661 774 597 1218 939 1144 829 187 1561 790 327 718 1604 830 1581 654 1274 685 92 106 49 1409 253 708 806 311